Your next great diversity job awaits you

Enter any job title, skill, company...

Nationwide Search

Enter city, state or zip

Local Search ADVANCED SEARCH
    

What's Wrong With Resumes


What's wrong with using resumes for hiring? Pretty much Everything  -

by
Dr. John Sullivan

If you’re getting low quality hires, it’s time to realize that the blind and uneducated use of resumes may be a main contributing factor (note that earlier this year I completed a similar analysis on interviews, the second major contributor to low quality hires). Resumes are the currency of recruiting. Job sites, recruiters, and hiring managers all require them and use them to screen both prospects and candidates in or out.

 

Because at least early on, resumes are the sole determinant as to whether a candidate moves forward or not in the hiring process, it’s important to understand their strengths and weaknesses. Many authors, (including myself and recruiting thought leader Kevin Wheeler) have been forecasting the demise of the resume for years. But despite their many faults, resumes have remained an essential part of the candidate assessment process. The premise of this article is that if you are going to continue to rely so heavily on resumes, everyone involved needs to be aware of each and every one of the many weaknesses and problems associated with using them.

 

The Top 30 Problems Related to Using Resumes for Hiring

The flaws, the weaknesses, and problems associated with resumes are many. I have listed the top 30 problems, divided into five distinct categories.

 

The top five factors that most negatively impact the quality of hire

Of all of the flaws, these five have the highest impact on new-hire quality.

  1. Resumes are at best, self-reported descriptions of historical events – the very definition of a resume highlights its fundamental weakness. Rather than providing information that you really need to hire someone (examples of a candidate’s actual work or a description of what they could do in your job), resumes are merely self-reported narrative descriptions of the candidates’ past work. The bias and selective memory of the candidate frequently results in a less-than-accurate description of what actually occurred. Obviously because resumes are essentially job histories, they don’t tell you anything about the person’s character, how they would act in your job, and their potential.
  2. Resumes frequently contain untruths and half-truths – the next-most-serious problem with resumes is that if you rely on them, you are likely making decisions based on falsehoods. Everyone that has researched them agrees, in fact, that as many as 80% of resumes contain misleading statements. And on average, 53% contain actual lies (The biggest offenders are college students, where 92% of them admit to lying on their resume). Even CEOs lie on their resumes (e.g. at Yahoo). And because references are not usually checked until the end of the hiring process, many candidates will likely move forward based on this false information. Those who are 100% honest may actually be penalized (or even screened out) because recruiters and hiring managers often “discount” what they find on resumes by as much as 30%, to take into account the expected “half-truth” percentage. Individuals in science, the law, or finance would simply laugh at any process that consciously makes decisions based on reports that are known to be so exaggerated.
  3. Negative information is omitted — in addition to inaccuracies, resumes have many omissions. The most significant omission is that resumes almost universally contain no negative or non-positive information. Even though everyone has made errors and bad decisions in almost every job, they will certainly not be prominently found in any resume. If someone has been convicted, flunked out of school, had a bad performance appraisal, gotten fired, or failed on a project, it will almost never be found in the resume. Even though this information may be found out later, many early-stage recruiting decisions will have already been made based on this incomplete information.
  4. Resumes do not cover the future or your firm – resumes are 100% historical, so at their very best they only cover what you have done in the past at other firms. However, those making the hiring decision need to project into the future. They need to know how you will act in this job and at this company when you are faced with this firm’s current and future problems. But unfortunately, resumes don’t include forecasts or projections on how you would act differently in this job and working environment.
  5. Requiring an updated resume will restrict applications – most companies absolutely require an updated resume in order to apply for a position or become an employee referral. But most employed individuals (the so-called passives) do not have an updated resume readily available. So, requiring one in order be considered for a position will eliminate many top potential candidates who simply can’t find the time in their busy schedule to update their resume. To further compound the problem, some individuals feel that updating their resume is an act of disloyalty, so they won’t take that action until they have made the final determination to leave (meaning they won’t apply for your job until they have updated their resume). And even those who have decided to leave may be leery that providing a resume may put their current job unnecessarily at risk if their boss were to find out (note: an alternative approach is to let the recruiter use a LinkedIn profile).

READ ENTIRE ARTICLE.. CLICK HERE

DIVERSITY.COM FEATURED EMPLOYERS ARE HIRING NOW !  CHECK IT OUT !



Newest Diversity Featured Jobs
Diversity Critical Hire Jobs
Featured Diversity Employers
  • University of Virginia


    University of Virginia

    Welcome to Charlottesville, Virginia, home of the University of Virginia, one of the nation's first public universities. Charlottesville was rated by Money Magazine as the best place to live in the United States. ...


    City: Charlottesville


    State: Virginia

    « Read More »
  • University of Nevada,Las Vegas


    University of Nevada,Las Vegas

     In its 50-year history, UNLV has undergone an amazing transformation from a small branch college into a thriving urban research institution of 28,000 students and 3,300 faculty and staff. Along the way, the urban land-grant univ ...


    City: Las Vegas


    State: Nevada

    « Read More »
  • University of Massachusetts Amherst


    University of Massachusetts Amherst

    Something To Be Proud Of.For more than 140 years, the University of Massachusetts has provided high quality educational opportunities for Massachusetts residents and for students and faculty from all over the world. U ...


    City: Amherst


    State: Massachusetts

    « Read More »
  • University of Northern Colorado


    University of Northern Colorado

    With our rich history, dedicated faculty, active students and Division I athletic teams, we’re large enough to provide true university opportunities and small enough to treat students as individuals – it’s a place wh ...


    City: Greeley


    State: Colorado

    « Read More »
  • University of Iowa Health Care


    University of Iowa Health Care

    University of Iowa Health Care is a fully integrated academic medical center, uniting the UI Roy J. and Lucille A. Carver College of Medicine, University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics, and UI Physicians, the largest multi-specialty gr ...


    City: Iowa City


    State: Iowa

    « Read More »
  • Colorado League of Charter Schools


    Colorado League of Charter Schools

    The Colorado League of Charter Schools is a non-profit, membership organization dedicated to supporting the charter schools in the state. The League is committed to helping these schools reach higher levels of student ...


    City: Denver


    State: Colorado

    « Read More »
  • Raytheon


    Raytheon

    Raytheon: Aspiring to be the most admired defense and aerospace systems company through our world-class people and technology   Raytheon is a technology and innovation leader specializi ...


    City: Waltham


    State: Massachusetts

    « Read More »
  • UTC - United Technologies Research Center (UTRC)


    UTC - United Technologies Research Center (UTRC)

    United Technologies (UTC) is a diversified company that provides a broad range of high-technology products and services to the global aerospace and building systems industries. Our commercial businesses are Otis elevators and escalato ...


    City: Farmington


    State: Connecticut

    « Read More »
  • University of Florida


    University of Florida

    The University of Florida, founded in 1853, is a public, comprehensive university. The 2,000-acre suburban campus is located in Gainesville, 70 miles from Jacksonville.With about 51,000 students, the University of Florida at Gainesvil ...


    City: Gainesville


    State: Florida

    « Read More »
  • Metropolitan Water District of Southern California


    Metropolitan Water District of Southern California

    The Metropolitan Water District of Southern California is a regional wholesaler that delivers water to 26 member public agencies – 14 cities, 11 municipal water ...


    City: Los Angeles


    State: California

    « Read More »
  • UTC - United Technologies - Building & Industrial Systems


    UTC - United Technologies - Building & Industrial Systems

    United Technologies (UTC) is a diversified company that provides a broad range of high-technology products and services to the global aerospace and building systems industries. Our commercial businesses are Otis elevators and ...


    City: Farmington


    State: Connecticut

    « Read More »
  • University of Connecticut


    University of Connecticut

    The University of Connecticut is one of the top public research universities in the nation, with more than 30,000 students pursuing answers to critical questions in labs, lecture halls, and the community. Knowledge exp ...


    City: Storrs


    State: CT

    « Read More »
Friends Of Diversity
  • Lamp Rynearson & Associates


     Lamp Rynearson & Associates

    Leaving a Legacy of Enduring Improvements to Our Community   We act as an extension of your firm as we have for over 55 years. Lamp, Rynearson & Associates, a civil engineering, ...


    City: Omaha


    State: Nebraska

    « Read More »
  • 1st Farm Credit Services


    1st Farm Credit Services

    1stFarm Credit Services, based in Normal, Illinois, is the largest agricultural lender in Illinois. We are part of a nationwide network th ...


    City: Normal


    State: IL

    « Read More »
  • American Diabetes Association


    American Diabetes Association

    The moving force behind the work of the Association is a network of more than one million volunteers, a membership of more than 441,000 people with diabetes, their families and caregivers, a professional society of nearly 16,500 healt ...


    City:


    State:

    « Read More »
  • Brown University


    Brown University

    Located in historic Providence, Rhode Island and founded in 1764, Brown University is the seventh-oldest college in the United States. Brown is an independent, coeducational Ivy League institution comprising undergraduate and graduate ...


    City: Providence


    State: Rhode Island

    « Read More »
  • Buncombe County - North Carolina


    Buncombe County - North Carolina

    Thank you for your interest in employment with the County of Buncombe. Buncombe County wants to find the best qualified people available to serve its citizens. Everyone who applies cannot be hired, but your application will be given e ...


    City: Asheville


    State: North Carolina

    « Read More »
  • Chatham University


    Chatham University

    Now fully coed, Chatham University in Pittsburgh, PA, has over 2,100 undergraduate and graduate students in the School of Health Sciences; the Falk School of Sustainability; and the School of Arts, Science and Business. Chatham seeks ...


    City: Pittsburgh


    State: Pennsylvania

    « Read More »
  • Childrens Healthcare of Atlanta


    Childrens Healthcare of Atlanta

    At Children's, we know kids aren't simply tiny adults. They need specialized pediatric care. Our team makes sure your child is comfortable and happy while in our care. We're committed to making all kids better today and he ...


    City: Atlanta


    State: Georgia

    « Read More »
  • City of Bellevue,Washington


    City of Bellevue,Washington

    Bellevue is the fifth largest city in Washington, with a population of more than 130,000. It is the high-tech and retail center of the Eastside, with more than 130,000 jobs and a downtown skyline of gleaming high-rises.  ...


    City: Bellevue


    State: Washington

    « Read More »
  • Columbia University


    Columbia University

    For more than 250 years, Columbia has been a leader in higher education in the nation and around the world. At the core of our wide range of academic inquiry is the commitment to attract and engage the best minds in pursuit of greater ...


    City: New York


    State: NY

    « Read More »
  • CPS HR Consulting


    CPS HR Consulting

    Established in 1985 as a self-supporting public agency, CPS HR Consulting provides a full range of integrated HR solutions to government and nonprofit clients.Our strategic approach to human reso ...


    City: Sacramento


    State: California

    « Read More »
  • Diversity Talent



    As corporate diversity programs and initiatives continue to gain strength and gather momentum across the country, the boundaries of diversity are extending well beyond the more traditional concepts of race and sex to include sexual or ...


    City: Blairsville


    State: Georgia

    « Read More »
  • Harris


    Harris

    Today, Harris is one of the only companies concentrated exclusively on developing the trusted solutions that solve the toughest technology challenges faced by businesses and governments around the world. Its innovative solutions are d ...


    City: Clifton


    State: New Jersey

    « Read More »