What does an employee need to demonstrate to be seen as leadership material? If the answer is “executive presence,” the next question should be: What does that actually mean?

The bamboo ceiling gives employers a reason to examine how they answer that question, particularly when evaluating Asian professionals for advancement.

What Does “Bamboo Ceiling” Mean?

The bamboo ceiling refers to barriers that can limit Asian professionals’ advancement into leadership, particularly in U.S. workplaces. Research examines both differences in leadership attainment and the expectations that influence who is viewed as a potential leader (Lu et al., 2020; Shao, 2023).

The term needs careful use. Asian professionals do not share one background, communication style, or career experience. Findings about one subgroup should not be treated as facts about every Asian employee.

What Does the Research Show?

Leadership Expectations Can Favor Particular Communication Styles

Across nine studies, Lu et al. (2020) found that East Asians were less likely than South Asians and White participants to attain leadership positions in the settings examined.

Differences in assertiveness helped explain the leadership gap between East Asians and South Asians. The authors interpreted this as a mismatch between communication norms and American expectations of how leaders should communicate. They did not find lower motivation for work or leadership among East Asians compared with South Asians.

These are group-level findings from specific studies. They are not a basis for assuming how an individual communicates or whether that person wants to lead.

Stereotypes Can Influence Who Looks Like a Leader

Lu (2024) examined another possible barrier: perceptions of creativity.

In two experiments involving non-Asian Americans with managerial experience, East Asian American candidates with substantively identical profiles were perceived as less leader-like than candidates of other ethnicities. Lower perceived creativity helped explain that difference.

The distinction matters: This finding concerns how candidates were perceived. It does not establish that East Asian professionals are less creative.

The experiments used hypothetical candidate profiles, so their results should not be presented as a direct measure of actual workplace promotion rates.

Experiences Vary Within Asian Populations

Shao (2023), using the 2017 National Survey of College Graduates, found that managerial attainment varied by birthplace and where people received their education.

Foreign-born Asian workers who had received no U.S. education, or only higher education in the United States, were disadvantaged relative to U.S.-born White workers and other Asian groups. The education-related pattern was more pronounced among East Asian immigrants than South Asian immigrants.

Together, these studies caution against a single explanation for every Asian professional’s career. They also do not provide a current national estimate of the bamboo ceiling in 2026.

Why Does This Matter for Fair Opportunity?

For employers, the practical concern is whether leadership evaluation recognizes relevant ability.

A broad recruiting effort cannot answer that question on its own. Employers also need to examine what happens when qualified employees seek greater responsibility.

The research offers a reason to scrutinize vague judgments about leadership potential. A useful review question is: What evidence supports this assessment, and would we interpret the same evidence similarly for another candidate?

What Can Employers Review?

These practical suggestions follow from the concerns raised by the research; the cited studies do not establish them as proven solutions.

• Define leadership requirements. Replace broad labels such as “executive presence” with specific responsibilities, such as explaining decisions, resolving disagreements, or guiding a team through a project.

• Ask for evidence behind evaluations. If creativity matters, review ideas developed and problems solved. If communication matters, identify the audience, task, and standard being assessed.

• Discuss career goals directly. Ask employees about their interest in leadership and the experience they want to build. Avoid inferring ambition from personality or communication style.

• Make development opportunities clear. Explain how employees can access mentoring, lead assignments, and demonstrate readiness for promotion.

Final Thoughts

The bamboo ceiling is relevant to fair opportunity because it raises a concrete question: How do employers decide who has the potential to lead?

Clear expectations and evidence-based evaluation give employers a stronger basis for that decision. Each employee deserves to be assessed through their skills, contributions, and goals.

For employers: Connect with candidates from a broader talent pool through Diversity.com.

For job seekers: Explore job opportunities on Diversity.com and ask prospective employers how they identify and develop future leaders.

Get Started with Diversity.com

At Diversity.com, we connect employers with qualified candidates through inclusive hiring, and help job seekers find employers committed to it.

For Employers & HR Professionals:

✔ Post a job and reach candidates across healthcare, higher education, government, nonprofits, and private industry
✔ Browse our resources for guides, checklists, and reports on inclusive hiring
✔ Join our community in LinkedIn for hiring and compliance updates

For Job Seekers:

✔ Find Inclusive Jobs at organizations that chose to post here
✔ Create a free account to apply and get matched to new openings
✔ Browse our resources for career guides and tools

Have questions? Reach out to our team. We're here to support you.

Related Articles

• Culture Fit vs. Culture Add: What Employers Should Know

• What Is the Glass Cliff? How It Can Affect Underrepresented Leaders

• What Is the Broken Rung? How First Promotions Shape Women’s Careers

• Flexibility Stigma at Work: When Flexible Work Carries a Career Penalty

• What Is the Glass Escalator? Why Men Advance Faster in Female-Dominated Fields

• The Halo Effect in Hiring: How First Impressions Distort Candidate Evaluation

• Who Gets the Office Housework? How Non-Promotable Tasks Affect Career Equity

• Name Bias in Hiring: What Resume Studies Actually Show

• Fair Chance Hiring: What Employers Should Know About Criminal Records

• The Motherhood Penalty at Work: What Research Actually Shows

Sources & References

• Lu, J. G. (2024). A creativity stereotype perspective on the Bamboo Ceiling: Low perceived creativity explains the underrepresentation of East Asian leaders in the United States. Journal of Applied Psychology, 109(2), 238–256. https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0001135

• Lu, J. G., Nisbett, R. E., & Morris, M. W. (2020). Why East Asians but not South Asians are underrepresented in leadership positions in the United States. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 117(9), 4590–4600. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1918896117

• Shao, D. (2023). Is there a bamboo ceiling? The Asian-White gap in managerial attainment for college-educated workers. Sociology of Race and Ethnicity, 9(1), 87–102. https://doi.org/10.1177/23326492221114809