NEW! The 2025 DEI Workplace Report is Here

Get exclusive data, employer insights, and strategic takeaways to navigate today’s DEI challenges.

NEW! The 2025 DEI Workplace Report is Here

Get exclusive data, employer insights, and strategic takeaways to navigate today’s DEI challenges.

Text graphic with a dark blue background reading: ‘How to Design a Work Sample for Hiring, With a Task and Scoring Rubric’ in bold white and orange font. A Diversity.com Blog label is positioned in the bottom right corner.

How to Design a Work Sample for Hiring, With a Task and Scoring Rubric

November 17, 2026•8 min read

“Can you manage competing priorities?” is easy to answer in an interview.

At 9 a.m., when a workshop room falls through, a partner needs a headcount, and a manager wants a report, a hiring team can learn more by seeing what a candidate does first.

A work sample asks a candidate to complete a task that resembles part of the job. To design one, choose a skill the person needs when they start, give every candidate the information needed to do the task, and decide in advance what a satisfactory response looks like. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management (n.d.) recommends work samples for skills candidates are expected to bring to the role. A process your organization teaches during onboarding is a poor choice for an entry assessment.

Here’s how that works for a program coordinator, from the instructions a candidate receives to the notes a reviewer records.

What Should a Hiring Work Sample Measure?

Start with a decision the employee regularly makes. For a program coordinator who runs workshops, that might be: When several requests arrive at once, can this person spot which delay would affect participants, take a practical first step, and tell colleagues what happens next?

That question sets the boundaries of the exercise. The candidate needs to know the deadlines, who can help, and what information is still missing. They can demonstrate judgment in a short written handoff. A slide deck, a full event plan, or familiarity with the employer’s scheduling software would add work without helping the reviewer answer the question.

Before giving the exercise to a candidate, ask someone who does the job to try it using only the written instructions. If their first reaction is “Everyone here knows to call Maya,” the prompt is missing a fact. Tell candidates who handles room changes, then let them decide when to contact that person.

What Does a Program Coordinator Work Sample Look Like?

The following is a fictional exercise for a role that involves coordinating workshops and writing short updates. A hiring team can adapt it to the responsibilities in its own job posting.

Candidate instructions

It’s 9 a.m. on Tuesday. You coordinate training workshops at two community centers. Three messages arrive at the same time.

  1. Workshop facilitator: “Our room is unavailable for today’s 10 a.m. workshop. Eighteen people are registered. The front desk can check for another accessible room and expects to have an answer by 9:15. Some participants leave home by 9:30.”

  2. Catering partner: “Please confirm tomorrow’s lunch count by 11 a.m. today so we can place the order. Our current estimate is 24.” You have the registration list and can check the count yourself.

  3. Program director: “Please send last month’s attendance summary by 3 p.m. for tomorrow’s board packet.” The attendance records are available.

Write a short handoff for the colleague covering the inbox with you. Put the three requests in the order you would handle them. For each, give your first action and a brief reason. Include what you would do if the front desk still hasn’t confirmed a room by 9:15. Then draft the message you would send the workshop facilitator while the room is being checked.

Please spend up to 20 minutes. Bullets are welcome. We’ll assess how you prioritize the requests, whether your next steps are workable, and whether the facilitator knows what to expect. You can use the facts on this page. If you need another fact, state what you would check.

The 20-minute limit is an example to test with your own team. Give candidates advance notice of the format, the time expectation, the tools they may use, and whom to contact about an accommodation. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2007) explains that covered employers may need to adjust how an assessment is administered so it measures the intended skill accurately.

How Should Reviewers Score the Work Sample?

Use one shared rubric and score each criterion separately. For this exercise, one point means the response shows partial evidence, and two points means it meets the stated expectation. Give zero when the response provides no relevant evidence for that criterion.

  • Prioritization. Give one point if the candidate identifies the room problem as urgent. Give two if they also explain the consequence of delay and account for the 11 a.m. and 3 p.m. deadlines. A candidate can earn full credit by asking a colleague to check the lunch count while they handle the room.

  • Next steps. Give two points if the candidate proposes a workable action for all three requests and a backup plan if the room remains unconfirmed at 9:15. Give one point if the response includes at least one workable action but leaves a request or the backup plan unresolved. Give zero if it offers no workable action.

  • Communication. Give one point if the message accurately describes the room issue but leaves the facilitator guessing about follow-up. Give two if it distinguishes confirmed facts from pending information and says who will provide the next update and when.

For example, a candidate writes to the facilitator: “I’ve asked the front desk to check for an accessible room. I’ll update you at 9:15 either way. If we still don’t have a room, I’ll call you then so we can decide what to tell participants before they leave home.” That earns two points for communication. The reviewer still needs to read the handoff to score prioritization and next steps.

Have reviewers score independently before discussing candidates. Beside each score, ask them to record the words or action that earned it. If one reviewer rewards a polished greeting and another rewards a promised update, the rubric tells them which detail matters for this job. The six-point total is a summary of this exercise. Before using it in hiring, decide how the team will weigh it alongside other evidence about the role.

Why Do Work Samples Matter for Diversity and Inclusion?

A library assistant who has handled a last-minute room closure may have exactly the judgment a workforce program needs, even if they have never held the title program coordinator. A realistic exercise gives that applicant a way to demonstrate the skill directly. It also gives a candidate with the familiar title an opportunity to show how they would handle the same decision.

The design determines whether that opportunity is meaningful. If the panel quietly rewards candidates who produce a polished presentation, applicants who follow the invitation and submit bullets face an undisclosed standard. If the exercise requires navigating an internal platform, prior exposure to that platform can influence the score. For this role, the relevant evidence is available in a few lines: Did the candidate notice when participants would leave home? Did they avoid announcing an unconfirmed room? Did someone take responsibility for the next update?

Diversity.com’s Before You Interview guide includes worksheets for connecting assessment criteria to the role and planning how candidates will participate (Diversity.com, n.d.).

Conclusion

Before sending a work sample, give the prompt and rubric to two reviewers along with the same practice response. Ask them to score it separately. If one gives full credit and the other gives partial credit, find the sentence or criterion behind the disagreement. That is the moment to revise the exercise, while every applicant can still receive the same instructions.

For the program coordinator role, the decisive detail might be a single sentence promising the facilitator an update before participants leave home. If that is what good judgment looks like on the job, the candidate prompt should give people a chance to demonstrate it, and the rubric should give them credit when they do.


Get Started with Diversity.com

At Diversity.com, we connect employers with qualified candidates through inclusive hiring, and help job seekers find employers committed to it.

For Employers & HR Professionals:

✔ Post a job and reach candidates across healthcare, higher education, government, nonprofits, and private industry
✔ Browse our resources for guides, checklists, and reports on inclusive hiring
✔ Join our community in LinkedIn for hiring and compliance updates

For Job Seekers:

✔ Find Inclusive Jobs at organizations that chose to post here
✔ Create a free account to apply and get matched to new openings
✔ Browse our resources for career guides and tools

Have questions? Reach out to our team. We're here to support you.


Frequently Asked Questions

Does every candidate need to choose the same order?

Several sequences can earn full credit if they protect participants and meet the deadlines. One candidate might call the front desk first. Another might ask their colleague to make that call while they update the facilitator. Reviewers should be able to explain how either response handles the risk.

How long should a hiring work sample take?

Use the shortest exercise that gives reviewers enough evidence to assess the skill. For this example, try the 20-minute limit with someone who performs the role. If most of their time goes into formatting or deciphering instructions, simplify the task. If speed matters on the job, explain how it will factor into scoring.

Can a hiring team use a current business problem?

A fictionalized version usually works well for an exercise like this. Change the names, dates, and operational details, and give each candidate the same brief. A simulated handoff lets the team assess judgment while keeping participant information private and the organization’s live work with its staff.


Related Articles


Sources & References

Back to Blog

2025 DEI Workplace Report: Critical Insights on the Future of Inclusive Workplaces

DEI is at a crossroads.

Political shifts, legal challenges, and economic uncertainty are forcing businesses to rethink their inclusion efforts.

Where do employers stand today, and what’s next for DEI?

✔ See what’s changing in DEI hiring and retention and how top companies are responding.

✔ Uncover the biggest risks of scaling back DEI and what it means for your workforce.

✔ Get expert-backed strategies to build an inclusive workplace that drives real business results.

2025 DEI Workplace Report: Critical Insights on the Future of Inclusive Workplaces

DEI is at a crossroads.

Political shifts, legal challenges, and economic uncertainty are forcing businesses to rethink their inclusion efforts.

Where do employers stand today, and what’s next for DEI?

✔ See what’s changing in DEI hiring and retention and how top companies are responding.

✔ Uncover the biggest risks of scaling back DEI and what it means for your workforce.

✔ Get expert-backed strategies to build an inclusive workplace that drives real business results.

Stay Informed, Stay Ahead with The Diversity.com Roundup

Your source for workplace trends, hiring insights, and career opportunities, delivered straight to your inbox.